The reason that behavioural interviewing is so popular is that it is predicated on the very logical belief that past performance indicates future performance. It is the same with most performance. We can look at the what has or has not worked in the past to make a fair determination of whether it will or will not work in the present/future. Thus the famous quote that insanity is doing the same thing over again and expecting a differrent result. That is why I found this article by Victor Davis Hanson in the National Review so interesting. Hanson talks about President Obama’s economic policies and how he is trying to turn the clock back to the 60’s and 70’s to policies that did not work.
What I find interesting is that so many very smart people believe that centralized economic planning can work. It has never, in the history of mankind, done anything but create poverty and war. The problem is that mankind and our economy is so fluid that nobody can ‘control’ it. The reason that some people have is their own hubris and ‘false ego’. They think they are smarter and/or want more power that they want to control everything. These leaders often end up creating their own demise as we see time and time again.
The problem with ideology is that people hold onto beliefs no matter what the evidence is. It is the same for people on the ‘other’ side of the political spectrum. For instance, the idea that government should not do anything. This extends to healthcare. There are some things that should be provided by government. The facts, for instance, on healthcare in systems that are government funded (i.e. Canada) versus fully private (i.e. U.S.). The facts speak for themselves. Canadians spent less per capita for healthcare than Americans do. The infant mortality rate in Canada is significantly lower than the U.S. and the average lifespan in the population is higher. Yes, there are wait times for ‘non emergency’ services (i.e. MRIs), but overall it does work better.
As I write in Flexible Thinker, the problems we have to overcome are the ones we ourselves control (i.e. preconceived ideas, false ego, etc.). Can the Canadian healthcare system be improved by some type of competition? Yes. However, when we shut ourselves off to looking for solutions that work (and have worked) because of ideology, we become the problem and not the solution.